image image
Psychology of Prophetism
Negationism in India - Concealing the Record of Islam
Found and Lost: the Ayodhya Evidence PDF Print E-mail
(0 votes, average 0 out of 5)
Articles - Ayodhya Debate
Written by Administrator   
Sunday, 20 July 2003 18:00
Article Index
Found and Lost: the Ayodhya Evidence
Page 2
Page 3
Page 4
Page 5
Page 6
Page 7
All Pages

Found and Lost: the Ayodhya Evidence

Dr. Koenraad Elst

(21 July 2003)

The North-Indian town of Ayodhya is scene to a controversy over a Hindu sacred site, the Rama Janmabhoomi or "birthplace of Rama".  That is where a mosque, the Babri Masjid, was built in forcible replacement of an earlier Hindu temple, in 1528 under Moghul emperor Babar at the latest, and demolished by a Hindu crowd in 1992.  The controversy pits Hindu activists against a combine of Muslim activists and the so-called "secularists", an array of Hindu-born Marxists and US-oriented 'globalists' who share a hatred of Hindu assertiveness.  The matter has been sub-judice at the High Court of nearby Allahabad since 1950, when Hindus had taken control of the mosque by installing statues of the deified hero Rama, his wife Sita and his brother Lakshmana.  Now, Hindu organisations are preparing to build a proper temple at the site.  Muslims organisations are reclaiming the site, and the judges have endlessly been postponing their intervention. 

At least until the winter of 2002-2003, for then the court secretly asked a specialized firm to scan the underground by radar for traces of the foundation of a temple predating the mosque.  One of the questions on which a verdict could arguably be based, was whether there had indeed been a temple at the site before the mosque was built.

A Splendid Consensus

Actually, until 1989 there had been no question about the site's history.  All the written sources, whether Hindu, Muslim or European, were in agreement about the pre-existence of a Rama temple at the site.  "Rama's birthplace is marked by a mosque, erected by the Moghul emperor Babar in 1528 on the site of an earlier temple", according to the 1989 edition of the Encyclopaedia Britannica, entry "Ayodhya".  Neither was there any document contradicting this scenario: no account of a forest chopped down to make way for the mosque (already unlikely in the centre of an ancient town), no sales contract of real estate to the mosque's builder, nothing of the kind.  By contrast, there was testimony after testimony of Hindus bewailing and Muslims boasting of the replacement of the temple with a mosque; and of Hindus under Muslim rule coming as close as possible to the site in order to celebrate Rama's birthday every year in April, in continuation of the practice at the time when the temple stood. 

And if authors of testimonies may be unreliable, there was also the archaeological evidence: in the 1970s, a team of the Archaeological Survey of India led by Prof. B.B. Lal dug out some trenches just outside the mosque and found rows of pillar-bases which must have supported a larger building predating the mosque.  Moreover, in the mosque itself, small black pillars with Hindu sculptures had been incorporated, a traditional practice in mosques built in forcible replacement of infidel temples to flaunt the victory of Islam over Paganism. 

The only remaining question about the site was its status in the period 1192-1528.  In 1192 and the subsequent years, practically all the Hindu temples and Buddhist monasteries in North India were demolished by Mohammed Ghori and his Turkish invaders.  It is impossible that the medieval temple at the site could have survived until 1528.  The most likely scenario is the one well-attested at another famous temple site: the Somnath temple in Gujarat.  No less than nine times did Hindus reclaim it as a temple, until Muslims retook it and turned it into a mosque again.  Since Ayodhya was a provincial capital of the Delhi Sultanate, opportunities for wresting the site from Muslim control were certainly more limited than in the case of the outlying Somnath temple.  Then again, the frequent infighting among the Muslim elite may have given rebellious Hindus some opportunities too.  From peculiarities in the architecture of the Babri Masjid, art historians on both sides of the debate (Sushil Srivastava, R. Nath) have deduced that the main part of the structure had been built well before the Moghul invasion, probably in the 14th century.  In that case, the tradition that it was built by Mir Baqi may be based on the following scenario: towards the end of the Sultanate period, Hindus may have managed to recapture the site and to turn it into a functioning temple, until Babar and his lieutenant Mir Baqi firmly imposed Muslim control again and gave some finishing touches to the mosque architecture in replacement of any Hindu elements that had come to adorn it.  But this must for now be kept inside speculative brackets.  What is certain is that a major Hindu temple at the site was demolished by Islamic iconoclasm and replaced with a mosque symbolizing the victory of Islam over Infidelism.  Of that, evidence is plentiful and of many types.



Comments (11)
  • fd  - fdfdf

    "Wow! wow power levelingThese videos are just amazing! These videos are an absolute goldmine for new players and skilled players!"-Anand wow power leveling
    "I was considering buying some gold from a site.buy wow gold.php?fid=7656]aion kina[/url] Then I came across Dan's strategies. They gave me a new insight into howcheap aion power leveling to make gold. He made it look so easy. I tried a few of his tactics and was amazed at how fast I managed to make aion power levelgold."aion kinah
    Thanks alot :) -Joel "So far I've made 100g on my 36 Rogue! It really works!重庆二手电脑 I love it!"-Josh
  • fdfd  - fd

    My Guide Passes the wow power leveling“No B.S” Test -It Must be 100% Legal - If you makes lots of gold but then get banned right wow power levelingaway—there's no point. wow gold ukAll my strategies will not get you banned, I guarantee it!No Membership Fees - Unlike my competition, I don't expect cheapest wow goldyou to fork out $39 a month for the same information I'm providing you; I give the straight facts to you all at once, not piddling advice gold for wowstrung out over months and months.Free Updates - World of Warcraft is always being updated and something written today could be completely useless tomorrow —that's why you'll get FREE updates.Covers All Levels as well as Alliance and Horde – There’s no point in forking out heaps of money only to find that it only covers Level 70 characters. How would that help you make more gold on your Level 37 character?
    Plus Think of How Much Money You'll Save Or Even Make!
  • wowgold  - wow gold
    2.8L Dawn of War 2: The Rise of Chaos Discover the trailers and demowow gold Dress goods, baby crib warm favorite bedroom (Chart) wow gold Fairy passers-by six Menpai History wow power leveling Akira hill music by adding "a hero is no longer" team cheap wow gold Sunday the latest notice of Pokemon pocket clip for development of new World of Warcraft Gold Photos: Beauty Xin Zhang for sexy photos out of bed lovely show wow power leveling Sony-speak about love, Huizhou real skill to start the sweet moments buy wow gold Spring Song - CAI Yu-Chin water to the opening of the new portrait World of Warcraft Gold Mayday come Xbox360 explosion of popular amusement park.
  • replica rolex  - replica watches
    2.8L Summer sale "LOVE PLUS" super-cute heroine clay hand for open louis vuitton Splinter Cell: conviction Japanese edition on sale April 28 louis vuitton Tianyuan Nether Palace, the most clever mouse demon companion Jiuyou louis vuitton Explosive turn Gyro King into Europe! Nikeluoding to buy broadcasting rights replica watches Chocolate CD Frame: shiny sweet gifts replica watches Le action game nearly a hundred children with the experience (Figure) replica watches Actor Kato Shahi endorsement on clothes "Dream Dragon" (Map) replica watches The nation's largest e-sports platform to settle Shijingshan replica watches So addicted to online games is wrong with new tactics to prevent: Parents can titles rolex watches Gucci Spring-Summer 2010 will be available for sale three sailing shoes tag heuer Playing adventure game "empty sound of Maiden Quintet" official website open! tag heuer Newcomers into the 3D online games, "Valkyrie," on-line Jiu Ji-ho li lo...
  • ghd hair straighteners  - hair straighteners
    2.8L SOCOM 3 demo version free of charge on landing PSN service ghd hair straightener Explosive turn Gyro King into Europe! Nikeluoding to buy broadcasting rights chi hair straightener Development party seeking to continue to improve, "Alpha Protocol" until the summer ghd hair straightener PSP3000 video game prices rose a record high before the Spring Festival chi hair straightener Fairy passers-by personal experience - Pet Synthetic Full Gonglue hair straightener Taipei Game Show Sony lovely showgirl Atlas ghd hair straightener Shirley Yeung attended the Spring Festival activities and the people playing fun games hair straight World of Warcraft Valentine's Day will fall the task Gonglue Shadowfang rocket mounts ghd hair straightener Chocolate CD Frame: shiny sweet gifts ghd hair Four mad God Wars absolutely unimaginable Level Break System debut ghd straightener Funny picture 恶搞 innocent fun like hair straight New nonsense muscle aging mother as a "San San people thing&#...
  • ed-hardy  - http://www.ed-hardy.cc/
    Ed Hardy clothing often use some embroidery, washing, splash-ink and other techniques, to create a feeling of decadence erosion, don ed hardyand then combined in the master reverberates from the Eagle, tiger skeletons, demons, daggers, and nudes, etc. tattoo, producing a series of Clothes. Another strong oriental taste of the carp, Nike star shoesa dragon and the tiger totem, the tiger dogs and squirrels are a relatively new breed of cartoon creation. Therefore, a launch that is loved by the general public,nike shoes embroidered totem tattoos baseball cap network is a collection value into hot commodities.
Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Comment:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img]   
:D:angry::angry-red::evil::idea::love::x:no-comments::ooo::pirate::?::(
:sleep::););)):0
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
Last Updated on Sunday, 30 September 2007 12:34
 
Pansoft Technologies